The Deep Scars of Sexual Abuse

According to one victim of sexual abuse: “Though I still become caught in fear and anger, each day I become more aware of the power I possess to choose love.  The most powerful words given to me during this painful process of healing came from Martin Luther King, Sr.:  ‘No matter what you do to me, I will not give you the power to make me hate.’”[i]  Those words are significant and powerful especially for those persons who have been sexually abused or suffered trauma in their life.  Many victims of childhood sexual abuse have so much pain and anger that they have difficulty functioning in everyday life.  Because the trauma is so deep and painful, many victims either keep quiet, suffer in silence or lash out in hate and rage as a result of the deep scars that have not been healed.

The problem neuroscience has taught us is “we can never erase or completely work through a traumatic experience because it remains encoded in our neurophysiology (and) there is no such thing as working something through once and for all.”[ii] These are very problematic findings that lead us to believe that many victims of sexual abuse and trauma have to live with this all the days of their lives.

It is important that we understand what the word trauma means.  Trauma means wound.  It “has come to describe an extremely distressing and harrowing personal or communal experience that exceeds our normal abilities to cope.   Traumatic experiences can leave us feeling overwhelmed, emotionally flooded, disoriented, unsure of ourselves, no longer able to trust others or our ability to perceive reality correctly.  Experiences of trauma can result in what has become known as posttraumatic stress disorder or what Judith Herman more accurately calls ‘complex post-traumatic stress disorder’ because ‘the responses to trauma are best understood as a spectrum of conditions rather than as a single disorder.’”[iii]  Understanding this diagnosis is very important.  Transforming the effects of sexual abuse or the trauma into a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder is a more relevant and descriptive diagnosis than what many had thought in the past.  As it pertains to law, there is no separate category for post-traumatic stress syndrome; rather they categorize it, unfortunately, as mental insanity.  This is how these conditions have come to be misunderstood in the legislature and court system.  If we legitimized a diagnosis of trauma, we would be better able to treat those that suffer from this condition.

Data on sexual abuse victims tells us that the trauma involved is difficult not only for the victim to understand, but also to process.  Children who have experienced sexual abuse throughout their life often times try to repress their memories of the event in order to try to function in a normal way.  We know that “child victims of sexual abuse face secondary trauma in the crisis of discovery.  Their attempts to reconcile their private experiences with the realities of the outer world are assaulted by the disbelief, blame and rejection they experience from adults.  The normal coping behavior of the child contradicts the entrenched beliefs and expectations typically held by adults, stigmatizing the child with charges of lying, manipulating or imagining from parents, courts, and clinicians.”[iv]

This is an exchange between a woman and the father who abused her when she was a child.  This case is typical of the denial and accusations that victims go through when they are sexually abused. It also highlights how the abuse continues when the victim is not believed.  This is what the father wrote:

“You were a very happy child growing up.  An evil psychiatrist has implanted a hypnotic suggestion into your mind.  As your father, and as a professional, I demand that you get a new psychiatrist, an M.D.  And I want a letter from him stating that you are in his care.  If you do not do this immediately, I will sever all further relationship with you.  Love, Dad.”[v]

 

This is what the victim wrote:

“‘First of all it was not hypnotic implantation.  I remember being molested.  It’s that simple.  I remember how and when and where it happened.  It’s instant recall, Dad.  Secondly, I’m not going to change counselors.’  I told my father that I was going to heal this wound, and that I’d do it with him or without him.”[vi]

 

This  case study shows  how typical it is for abusers to not only continue  manipulating their victims of abuse,  but it also illustrates how these victims of abuse have to fight through the pain, hurt, and unbelief in order to achieve healing.

“Most persons who have been traumatized remember their traumatic experiences relatively clearly.  They’ve never forgotten them, and they have no doubt about what happened.  For others, like the woman whose exploration of her anxiety led to a revelation of childhood sexual molestation, matters are not so clear.  These persons may have gone for years – even decades – without remembering various traumatic childhood experiences.  Then, seemingly out of nowhere, images suggestive of traumatic experience start coming to mind.”[vii]  “Although the concept is controversial, repression can play a role in not remembering traumatic events.  When we deliberately avoid trying to think about something – often making matters worse – we are employing suppression. In contrast, repression is an automatic, nonconscious process that inhibits emotionally painful thoughts and memories from being elaborated in consciousness.”[viii]

Many victims of sexual abuse have used these mental techniques daily, not realizing they were causing more emotional damage.  “Sadly, trauma does not necessarily end when the traumatic situation is long past.  Many traumatized persons continue to re-experience the trauma wherever memories of the event are evoked.  Along with the memories come painful emotions and the sense of helplessness.”[ix] Additionally, “Many persons are blindsided by flashbacks that have been triggered out of the blue by some reminder of trauma.  Not uncommonly, the triggers are hard to identify, compounding fear with bewilderment.  Traumatic memories also intrude into sleep in the form of nightmares.  Flashbacks and nightmares can be relatively direct replicas of the traumatic experience.  Some traumatic events are remembered and relived with crystal clarity, in full detail, accompanied by a coherent sense of what happened.  These are prototypical personal event memories, albeit with a traumatic intensity of emotion.”[x]  Unfortunately, many victims of sexual abuse experience these phenomena on a regular basis.

These are some of the significant ramifications for those who have experienced this type of trauma.  It is regrettable that the trauma and these memories are things that many of these victims are never able to forget or get over.  Unfortunately, many times the victims do not have the resources to find competent and capable counseling in order to come to a healing place with regard to what happened in their life. In this instance, many continue this vicious cycle of abuse long after the abuse has stopped.

“A century ago, Freud labored to understand the causes of debilitating symptoms, including anxiety, depression, suicide attempts, painful physical sensations, and eruptions of intense emotions associated with images of hallucinatory vividness.  He had worked with 18 patients with such symptoms and concluded that in every instance, the symptoms were connected with sexual trauma in early childhood.”[xi]

Almost every single victim of sexual abuse that I have worked with as a lawyer, advocate and pastor had issues of anxiety, depression, suicide attempts, painful physical sensations, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, and vivid hallucinations or flashbacks.  These are commonplace for those who have been sexually abused and many times they live for years in silence with these effects.

The traumatic events and abuse disrupts an individual’s secure base and destroys the basic trust humans’ need in order to function.  It also deeply disturbs physiological regulation.  Often a kind of double whammy results here: the traumatic experience generates hyperarousal (fear, panic, pain), and when the individual is then abandoned or neglected after being injured and aroused it compounds the negative effects of the experience.[xii]

So, it is very important that a secure attachment relationship develops for the victims of sexual abuse in order for them to attain a ‘safe-haven’.  Along with physical protection, secure attachment provides a feeling of security.  The victims need to be physically safe and to feel emotionally secure enough to heal.  Trauma undermines both; a healing attachment relationship restores both.[xiii]

Without doubt, sexual abuse has significant and lasting effects on its victims.  Many victims live in silence and keep the abuse secret all their lives.  They may keep it silent, but it still has tremendous physical and psychological effects on the well-being of the whole person.  The court system and the legislature must expand the protection afforded victims of sexual abuse not only allow healing and closure, but to recognize and seek justice for their harm.

 

[i] Bass, Ellen, and Laura Davis. “Gizelle.” The Courage to Heal: A Guide for Women Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse. New York: Perennial Library, 1988. p. 446. Print.

[ii] Van Den Blink, Han. “Trauma and Spirituality.” Reflective Practice: Formation and Supervision in Ministry 28 (2008): p. 41. Print.

 

[iii] Ibid, p. 31. (internal citations omitted)

[iv] Summit, Roland, C. M.D., “The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome.”, Child Abuse & Neglect, Vol. 7, p 1

[v] Bass, Ellen, and Laura Davis. “Gizelle.” The Courage to Heal: A Guide for Women Survivors of Child Sexual Abuse. New York: Perennial Library, 1988. p. 453. Print.

[vi] Ibid, p. 453.

[vii] Allen, Jon G., “Memory”, Coping with Trauma: Hope through Understanding., Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Pub., 2005. p. 87. Print.

[viii] Ibid, p. 92. (internal citations omitted)

[ix] Ibid. p. 79.

[x] Ibid, p. 83-84.

[xi] Ibid, p. 88. (internal citations omitted)

[xii] Allen, Jon G., “Attachment”, Coping with Trauma: Hope through Understanding., Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Pub., 2005. p. 29. Print.

[xiii] Ibid, p. 27.

Advertisements

What Victims of Sexual Abuse Need to Know About New Jersey’s Statute of Limitations

Recently, a New Jersey man, J.D., filed suit against his former Spanish teacher, Ratner, for the abuse she committed against him when he was sixteen years old and a student in her class. This case was covered by the media (see i.e., N.J. teacher accused of sex with student 30 years ago placed on leave; Why this N.J. teacher is shielded from sex-with-student charge).

Many of the comments on these stories question why a student can bring a sexual assault claim stemming from sexual abuse thirty years ago. In New Jersey, the standard statute of limitations for any and all personal injuries, including sexual abuse, require that all personal injury cases commence within two years.  See N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2 and 2A:61 B-1 (b).

However, with sexual abuse, the statute of limitations is essentially put on pause where the victim has suffered from psychological, physical, mental or emotional problems as a result of the abuse and has not fully realized the scope of the abuse. The statute of limitations does not begin to run until the victim of the sexual abuse both realizes that he/she is a victim of sexual abuse AND relates the sexual abuse to the physical, psychological, mental and emotional harm that they have suffered.

Victims of child sexual assault and abuse do indeed suffer greatly. Studies that there is “a powerful relationship between our emotional experiences as children and our physical and mental health as adults….traumatic emotional experiences in childhood (grow) into organic disease later in life.”10 (Felitti, Vincent J., MD. “The Relationship of Adverse Childhood Experiences to Adult Heath: Turning Gold into Lead.” Kaiser Permanente Medical Care Program., n.p., 2002. Web. ).  Many victims of childhood sexual abuse experience alcohol abuse, drug abuse, chronic depression, morbid obesity, diabetes, hypertension, coronary artery disease and many other effects.

In the case of J.D., the sexual abuse by his Spanish teacher continued for nine years and she twice became pregnant. Both pregnancies ended in abortions. Following the abuse, J.D. continued to be involved with Ratner and her family. However, in 2013, J.D. started to have intense and frequent panic attacks. He had to be hospitalized and was diagnosed with depression and anxiety disorder.

The diagnosis prompted counselor’s visits and treatment that ultimately resulted in a breakthrough on May 14, 2015, during which J.D. realized sexual abuse was to blame for his emotional issues. Because J.D. did not realize that he was a victim of sexual abuse and that sexual abuse was the cause of his ongoing psychological and emotional harm until May 14, 2015, the statute of limitations on J.D.’s case did not begin to run until May 14, 2015.

J.D.’s delayed realization that the “relationship” he experienced was actually sexual abuse is not uncommon. Data on sexual abuse victims tells us that the trauma involved in sexual abuse is difficult to not only understand but also to process. (Summit, Roland, C. M.D., “The Child Sexual Abuse Accommodation Syndrome.”, Child Abuse & Neglect, Vol. 7). Many children who are victims of sexual abuse will repress or deny their memories in order to function in daily life. Many victims of sexual abuse are ill-equipped on their own to deal with these issues. They are afraid to come forward for fear of unbelief; that they are lying, and that they are manipulating and fearful of being rejected or abused again.